Comparisons
Magnetic vs sliding vs screw-top acrylic case lids
4 min readUpdated on 2 November 2026

A case only protects your collectible while it's closed. How it closes decides how easily you get at your collectible, and how easily the lid comes off when you don't want it to.
Magnetic vs sliding acrylic case: the choice comes down to easy access versus security, with screw tops at the far end. A magnetic lid lifts off with one hand and goes back just as quickly, which suits collectibles you look at or take out often. A sliding lid runs in a groove, so it can't be lifted off, but you need room beside the case to slide it out. Screws hold a case shut most firmly, and the price is reaching for a screwdriver every time you want in. For a collectible that stays in its case for years, or one that gets handled by other people, that's no hardship.
While the lid is on, the walls take the knocks whatever the closure. The difference is in opening and closing, and in what happens when the case is dropped or picked up the wrong way.
| Magnetic | Sliding | Screws | |
|---|---|---|---|
| To open | lift the lid off | slide the lid out | undo the screws |
| Room needed | above | beside | for a screwdriver |
| Lid off if lifted by it | yes | no | no |
| Loose parts | none | none | screws |
| Good for | frequent viewing | moving around | staying shut, travel |
Magnetic: quick on, quick off
With a magnetic closure, small magnets set into the edge of the case hold the lid in place. You lift the lid off, take your collectible out or put it in, and set the lid back down. It settles into place by itself. There's nothing to unscrew and nothing to lose.
The drawback follows from that: only the magnets hold the lid on. Pick the case up by its lid and the lid comes away; drop the case and the lid can fly off. So hold a magnetic case by its walls, with both hands, not by the lid.
You won't know how firmly a lid holds until the case is in your hands. What you can see:
- Are the magnets flush with the acrylic, with no glue ridge or raised edge?
- Does the lid drop into place at every corner without you nudging it?
- Does it sit level all round, with no gap?
All our cases close with magnets. The photo at the top shows the magnets in the edge of one of our cases.

Booster Box Case
€11.99In stock
Sliding lid: it can't come off
A sliding lid is a panel that runs in grooves in the walls. You slide it out and slide it back. There's no lifting it off: pick the case up and the lid stays in its groove.
The flip side is that you need room in the direction the lid slides. If the case sits in a full cupboard or between other cases on a shelf, you'll have to move it before the lid will open. And if your collectible comes right up to the underside of the lid, the lid slides across the seal every time you open or close it.
What to check when you buy:
- Does the lid slide smoothly, without sticking or needing to be wiggled?
- Is there a gap between the lid and the top of your collectible?
- Does the lid stay in place when you tilt the case a little, or does it start sliding open?
Screws: the most secure
On a screw-top case, the lid or the walls are screwed together. The case won't come open by itself: not if it's dropped, not if someone picks it up by the lid, and not if it takes a knock in a moving box.
The downside shows the moment you want to get at your collectible. Opening and closing takes time and a screwdriver, and the screws are small enough to lose. For a collectible you like to take out now and then, that soon becomes a chore you'll skip.
What to check when you buy:
- Are the screw holes clean, with no hairline cracks in the acrylic around them?
- Do the screws go in without forcing? Tighten them until the lid is secure, and no further.
- Does it come with spare screws?
Which closure suits you?
- You take your collectible out now and then, or rotate what's on the shelf: magnetic.
- Other people can get at the case, say kids in the house, or it's coming to a card show: screws, or a sliding lid.
- Your collectible stays in its case for years and you only look at it: any closure works. Screws give the most security, magnets the most convenience.
If you're moving house or shipping a case, stand it upright in a box, lid on top, with padding all round so it can't shift. That matters most with a magnetic lid, since a jolt in transit can shake it loose.
Frequently asked questions
Can a magnetic case open by itself?
On a shelf, the lid stays put. It can come loose if you lift the case by the lid, if the case is dropped, or if it takes a knock in a box while being moved.
Which closure is the most secure?
Screws hold a case shut most firmly, and a sliding lid won't come off when you pick the case up. But while a case is closed, it's the walls that protect your collectible, not the closure. So choose mainly on how often you want to get at your collectible.
What closure do PokeShield cases have?
All our cases close with magnets. We don't make cases with sliding lids or screws.
Magnetic or screw top for an ETB?
It depends how often you want to get at it. If you take the ETB out now and then, or rotate what's on the shelf, a magnetic lid is far handier. If it'll stay shut for years, or sits where other people can get at it, screws give you more security.








